Re: Residents Divided Game Thread (Endgame)

[Sid_The_Kid]

Vote Count 3 of Day 1
Sid(2):Reverse,Darth
TKoE(2):Alex,Overlord
Darth(1):Sid
Not Voting (2): Rewind,TKoE

With 7 votes in play, it’s 4 to lynch.
Deadline is 2 Weeks:30th of May 12pm.
Rewind has been prodded

[Darth Skywalkerbacca]

@Overlord: Yes I do have a personality, though I don't think it does anything rolewise

[Reverse Simplicity]

Vote:Darth
early days ...

I'm going to suggest darth may actually be scum, due to this.

Sid has only the power that we choose to give him. Exaggeration is a scum tool.

Unvote

FoS:Darth

Not ready to vote at this point.

I will not confirm or deny that my role contains a personality.

[Supreme Overlord]

I will not confirm or deny that my role contains a personality.

And your thoughts on a personality massclaim?

[Sid_The_Kid]

Unvote

@RS:What makes you think that my RVS vote confirms Darth to be scum?

[Sid_The_Kid]

Vote Count 4 of Day 1
Sid(1):Darth
TKoE(2):Alex,Overlord
Not Voting (4): Rewind,TKoE,Sid,Reverse

With 7 votes in play, it’s 4 to lynch.
Deadline is 2 Weeks:30th of May 12pm.

[Supreme Overlord]

What about you, Sid? I suppose as mod you would have given yourself all the shiny new toys to play with - do you have a Personality, and what is it?

And guys, if you're online, you've got to say something - you can't just sit back and wait for somethin 'interesting' to happen. We're back to a normal (ish) game now; discussion is vital.

[Reverse Simplicity]

Unvote

@RS:What makes you think that my RVS vote confirms Darth to be scum?

Many things that I cannot put into text.

If I posted every time I was online... there would be many double posts by me, that add nothing to the post.

[Supreme Overlord]

If I posted every time I was online... there would be many double posts by me, that add nothing to the post.

That's fine when it's true. But I have asked you what is your opinion on massclaiming Personalities. I understand that at this point you don't want to claim whether or not you have a Personality, and that's fine for now. But I want to know if you have something against everybody claiming Personalities, or if you think it would be fine, or what?

[Reverse Simplicity]

I have not decided one way or the other. As far as darth is concerned they mean very little. But there is the chance that someones role has benefit from knowing personalities.

I would like to know if anyone is in a team. I thought this game was going to require more private team discussion than anything.

[Alex Steiner]

I'm with Reverse in this case - I'd feel safer keeping personality to myself. They exist for a reason, and I'm not sure if it's good for town or not to reveal that.

[Supreme Overlord]

I have not decided one way or the other.

I'm with Reverse in this case - I'd feel safer keeping personality to myself.

OK, got it. I'd still like to know the other people's opinions, though.

I would like to know if anyone is in a team. I thought this game was going to require more private team discussion than anything.

I think this is good information to claim; few downsides (if any) - although do you think there is merit in only one of a pair/team claiming, to protect the other/s? Although once you have the 'no team' and the 'speaker for the team' claims, it'll probably be easy enough to PoE the rest.

[Sid_The_Kid]

What about you, Sid? I suppose as mod you would have given yourself all the shiny new toys to play with - do you have a Personality, and what is it?

Nope, i don't have a Personality ... or too many "shiny new toys" either.

[The King of Eggs]

What about you, Sid? I suppose as mod you would have given yourself all the shiny new toys to play with - do you have a Personality, and what is it?

Nope, i don't have a Personality ... or too many "shiny new toys" either.

Ok, lets lynch him

Vote: Sid

[Darth Skywalkerbacca]

Unvote

I'm not up for a mass claim of personalities either, as Reverse said they were put in for a reason, I'm assuming some role depends on them and from the way Overlord is centering on them I'm beginning to think it's him or he's in a partnership with somebody who relies on it, and with some people saying they don't have personalities it's obvious that it only effects those that do so I'm not claiming.

My initial instincts this game are to go with Vote: Alex

[If I Could Rewind]

Hmmmm, well firstly I'll say that it's good to be back. Or rather it's good to be off LA and be posting in this thread for the first time. After a quick re-look over the rules and people's actions I'm starting to think that this game doesn't contain any town/mafia roles.

Anyway I think that I would like a no-lynch day 1 just because that's my gut instinct. I don't see the point in lynching anyone without relevant information, still that said I'd like to put pressure on someone, in the hope that information comes from it. The two biggest candidates right now are Eggs and Sid. Pressuring the mod (who is also a player) seems like a more profitable option than pressuring a player who is an unknown(eggs). Still that being said, I don't really like the unknown.

Vote: Eggs

As to the personality debate, I think that I'll have to agree with Reverse and Alex. I don't really see the point in sharing something that is really just added flavor, especially because people can and will try and use it as solid evidence against others. Instead of finding actual evidence (Yes I do this as well).

PS: I will probably change to no lynch by the end of the day, unless someone convinces me that it's a really bad idea.

[Supreme Overlord]

Ok, lets lynch him

Vote: Sid

I definitely agree that there's no point keeping him around if a better option doesn't present itself Day 1.

However:

After a quick re-look over the rules and people's actions I'm starting to think that this game doesn't contain any town/mafia roles.

You are wrong. Vote: Rewind

Anyway I think that I would like a no-lynch day 1 just because that's my gut instinct. I don't see the point in lynching anyone without relevant information, still that said I'd like to put pressure on someone, in the hope that information comes from it. The two biggest candidates right now are Eggs and Sid. Pressuring the mod (who is also a player) seems like a more profitable option than pressuring a player who is an unknown(eggs). Still that being said, I don't really like the unknown.

This is a mass of contradictions. Why do you think anyone will feel pressure if the know you don't actually intend to lynch them? How did you pick Eggs as one of the biggest candidates? Why would the mod feel any pressure when he knows exactly what you can/cannot do to him? And why on Earth did you say Sid was the more profitable option when you then turn around and vote Eggs?


And it looks like everyone has given an opinon on Personalities, except Sid and Eggs who appear not to have one. That's a majority of 'no', so I'll drop it.

[Darth Skywalkerbacca]

the fact that Rewind said there might not be any town/mafia roles does imply that he is a third, neutral party but that isn't enough to make me want to lynch him yet.

@Rewind: What alignment is your role?

[Reverse Simplicity]

vote: SO what makes you think iicr is wrong? What info do you have on the subject?

This is a mind screw. And eggs knows more about the set up that the rest of us. He helped design this scenario. That makes him dangerous for his enemies.

FoS:IICR a no lynch is almost always bad for town.

[Supreme Overlord]

vote: SO what makes you think iicr is wrong? What info do you have on the subject?

There is a Town. My role PM is clear. If Rewind did not know there was a Town, he is not part of it.

This is a mind screw.

Is it? I was under the impression that it was a normal, if a bit quirky, Mafia game. The rules are clear, my role PM was clear, and any questions I've had were answered to the extent that I'd expect in a regular game. Why do you think it's mind screw?

And eggs knows more about the set up that the rest of us. He helped design this scenario. That makes him dangerous for his enemies.

Was this answering my question to Rewind? If so, why are you answering for him? If not, why are you bringing up Eggs?

[The King of Eggs]

And eggs knows more about the set up that the rest of us. He helped design this scenario. That makes him dangerous for his enemies.

Was this answering my question to Rewind? If so, why are you answering for him? If not, why are you bringing up Eggs?

I'm more interested in why he automatically assumed I'd be counted as an enemy.

[Darth Skywalkerbacca]

As much as it is in everybody's nature to automatically assume Eggs is guilty of everything we have to fight that overwhelming urge to lynch until we have more solid proof of the fact.

[Sid_The_Kid]

Pressuring the mod (who is also a player) seems like a more profitable option than pressuring a player who is an unknown(eggs).

hmmm understandable ... just remember that i can only reveal,as a player, what my role pm allows me.

@Eggs: what makes you think that i should be Day 1 lynch?

[Sid_The_Kid]

Vote Count 5 of Day 1
Alex(1):Darth
Sid(1):TKoE
Overlord(1):Reverse
Rewind(1):Overlord
TKoE(2):Alex,Rewind
Not Voting (1): Sid

With 7 votes in play, it’s 4 to lynch.
Deadline is 2 Weeks:30th of May 12pm.

[Supreme Overlord]

Mod, Darth is voting for Alex.ModNote: Thanks,Vote Count Updated

just remember that i can only reveal,as a player, what my role pm allows me.

Out of academic interest, what safeguards have you put in place to restrict your power as mod? Self-aligned, specifically not allowed to reveal scum; what?

Also Sid, what are you basing your vote on (since it's not going to be based on scumhunting)?

[Sponsored content]