Publishing Cop Mafia

darth: if you were the third townie why wouldn't you vote ?
by not voting wouldn't that leave a required bus for town to stand a chance to win ?
that seems risky too risky for a townie especially since his greatest weapon is to vote ...

Vote Count 4 of Day 2

Supreme Overlord (1) - The King of Eggs

Not Voting (4) - Alex Steiner, Darth Skywalkerbacca, Reverse Simplicity, Sid_The_Kid

With 5 alive it's 3 to lynch.

Keep on track.
Activity's good for now.

you are forgetting the scum or assuming scum won't vote for each other which is a flaw in you logic scum have no reason not to vote for each other it may make them appear more town. There are enough townies and scum to lynch scum without my intervention.

Darth Skywalkerbacca wrote:you are forgetting the scum or assuming scum won't vote for each other which is a flaw in you logic scum have no reason not to vote for each other it may make them appear more town. There are enough townies and scum to lynch scum without my intervention.

You are correct. A bus is likely if Alex and Eggs correctly identify scum. But if you were town and allowed the scum to hammer, then it would confuse Alex and Eggs into thinking that you are scum. No matter how long this debate goes on for, not voting = scummy.

darth you say (if you're town) you wouldn't vote even since as the unkown townie you know exactly who the scum are ... seems like that would be a ploy to hinder the town ... vote:darth
RS: you have stated earlier that you believe me to be scum ... how did you come to that conclusion ?

That was... unintelligent.

In for a penny in for a pound

Good Game folks


VOTE: DARTH

<--- IS IDIOT

UNVOTE: DARTH

Reverse Simplicity wrote:

Darth Skywalkerbacca wrote:you are forgetting the scum or assuming scum won't vote for each other which is a flaw in you logic scum have no reason not to vote for each other it may make them appear more town. There are enough townies and scum to lynch scum without my intervention.

You are correct. A bus is likely if Alex and Eggs correctly identify scum. But if you were town and allowed the scum to hammer, then it would confuse Alex and Eggs into thinking that you are scum. No matter how long this debate goes on for, not voting = scummy.

Wrong RS. Even if I 'knew' that you (for example) where scum, I highly doubt that your partner would throw you under a bus, when waiting for deadline is a valid strategy. If Darth refuses to vote then the scum just have to wait us out (although this assumes Darth is town to begin with). Actually since I'm talking to two people and only one townie exists, shouldn't you be happy that a scum member is not voting?

you're right Sid the unkown townie does know who the scum are, are you making a townie claim by voting for me?
Because if you were townie you'd know I was scum and you really wouldn't need to waste time saying how my not voting is a ploy to hinder town, you could just claim town and say I'm scum.

a vote based on a townie claim has little credential value due to the possibility of a false claim ... thus my vote requires evidence behind it to increase its credability ...

The King of Eggs wrote:

Reverse Simplicity wrote:

Darth Skywalkerbacca wrote:you are forgetting the scum or assuming scum won't vote for each other which is a flaw in you logic scum have no reason not to vote for each other it may make them appear more town. There are enough townies and scum to lynch scum without my intervention.

You are correct. A bus is likely if Alex and Eggs correctly identify scum. But if you were town and allowed the scum to hammer, then it would confuse Alex and Eggs into thinking that you are scum. No matter how long this debate goes on for, not voting = scummy.

Wrong RS. Even if I 'knew' that you (for example) where scum, I highly doubt that your partner would throw you under a bus, when waiting for deadline is a valid strategy. If Darth refuses to vote then the scum just have to wait us out (although this assumes Darth is town to begin with). Actually since I'm talking to two people and only one townie exists, shouldn't you be happy that a scum member is not voting?

I was merely putting it out there clear as day, rather than it being potentially ignored.

Sid_The_Kid wrote:a vote based on a townie claim has little credential value due to the possibility of a false claim ... thus my vote requires evidence behind it to increase its credability ...

This sounds far too much like you are covering all bases. Also you jumped on darth quite quickly. Without a lot of discussion with the confirmed townies. In fact immediately after my post about how a bus is a valid statergy (Which eggs has proven false). This is also quite a scummy move.

I will be posting less as I feel I have said everything I need to say, I have made my accusations quite clear. Alex/Eggs feel free to ask any questions that you require.

RS. if you are so sure of Sid's scummyness then why dont u vote?

The King of Eggs wrote:RS. if you are so sure of Sid's scummyness then why dont u vote?

I have already stated that it is up to you and Alex to decide, you make up the tie breaker.

However. A compromise: unFoS: Alex, FoS: Darth, FoS: Sid

Vote Count 5 of Day 2

Darth Skywalkerbacca (1; L-2) - Sid_The_Kid

Not Voting (4) - Alex Steiner, Darth Skywalkerbacca, Reverse Simplicity, The King of Eggs

With 5 alive it's 3 to lynch.

Wow, Alex hasn't posted since Friday. Prodding.
The rest of you are doing fine.

Evidence or supposition it is all the same in this game Sid

I'm really not liking Reverse's hands-off wishy-washiness. He's starting to coalesce as my pick for today.

Darth is as mystifying as always. Please don't waste time with "townie claim" inferences. Unless otherwise stated, assume we all claimed townie, it makes life easier. I want everyone to vote (everyone except Eggs and I). I want justification. I want a pie.

Be back later.

Oh yes. Eggs. Please. Use the preview button. Think about what you wrote, and what you did. Then press post. Otherwise, just calm down .

darth as stated earlier i prefer to have a strong vote rather than a flimsy claim based vote ... it doesn't matter if i claim town or not as i have to convince eggs and AS that I'm town ... thus i let my actions speak for me supported by my arguements ...

Alex Steiner wrote:I'm really not liking Reverse's hands-off wishy-washiness. He's starting to coalesce as my pick for today.

Where have I been "hands-off wishy-washiness". This is you continuing to try and be lazy. It is up to you and eggs to discuss who is the remaining town, I have been ignored when saying this at least two other times.

Alex and Eggs have not discussed between who is town or scum, that would be like a scum team not discussing who to NK over quick topic.

Sid: Is willing to lynch myself or darth.
Darth, is accusing Sid and myself.
I am accusing Darth and Sid.

It requires three to lynch. Meaning we need Alex or Eggs to decide who they think is scum and vote. Don't try and push the responsibility onto us, take some of it for yourself and do some proper analysis. Consider my vote to be on both sid and darth, I believe them to be scum and have already pointed out why.

/end rant.

But, since you are clearly stuck on this, and scum are not going to be lynched without me doing so. Vote: Sid

Vote Count 6 of Day 2

Darth Skywalkerbacca (1; L-2) - Sid_The_Kid
Sid_The_Kid (1; L-2) - Reverse Simplicity

Not Voting (3) - Alex Steiner, Darth Skywalkerbacca, The King of Eggs

With 5 alive it's 3 to lynch.

Vote Count 7 of Day 2

Darth Skywalkerbacca (1; L-2) - Sid_The_Kid
Sid_The_Kid (1; L-2) - Reverse Simplicity

Not Voting (3) - Alex Steiner, Darth Skywalkerbacca, The King of Eggs

With 5 alive it's 3 to lynch.

Over 24 hours without activity makes me an unhappy mod.
Mass prod going out.
Get a lynch by Monday; Friday would be even better, to allow a Night over the weekend.

Seeing as how I am the most recent poster (Other than yourself) you could have skipped me.

I have nothing to add since my last post, this is literally just to get rid of the prod. If you need clarification or justification, just ask.

AS and eggs : you guys have the evidence and one vote against scum ... how are you guys still undecided ?
RS : why would i talk with AS and eggs if i had evidence to back up my vote ... as you said they must do some analysis for themselces rather then leaving it up to us three ... and by waiting to give my opinion i would've given the scum a chance to pounce on the townies mistakes ... so the sooner i got out my opinion the better for the town

Sid_The_Kid wrote:AS and eggs : you guys have the evidence and one vote against scum ... how are you guys still undecided ?
RS : why would i talk with AS and eggs if i had evidence to back up my vote ... as you said they must do some analysis for themselces rather then leaving it up to us three ... and by waiting to give my opinion i would've given the scum a chance to pounce on the townies mistakes ... so the sooner i got out my opinion the better for the town

Nice trying to get chummy there. My opinions are out in the open, I just don't see a reason to vote before Alex and Eggs decide who to lynch. You are not town, I have given my evidence towards that. And I never was telling you to talk to Alex or Eggs, will anyone read posts properly?

Vote Count 8 of Day 2

Darth Skywalkerbacca (1; L-2) - Sid_The_Kid
Sid_The_Kid (1; L-2) - Reverse Simplicity

Not Voting (3) - Alex Steiner, Darth Skywalkerbacca, The King of Eggs

With 5 alive it's 3 to lynch.

I realise I'm preaching to the converted here. Thanks for showing up. Carry on.

sorry I haven't been on oh great and powerful mod but I've been sick and couldn't be bothered.

ok my thinking dictates Alex and Eggs need give a top 1 scum list and reasons as to why so we can get some healthy butt kissing going on as they hold the power of life or death over our heads.

Also I apply Alex's warning to Reverse as well your posts are generally quite confusing (to me at least) you can argue your points more effectively if you take some time to edit your posts.