Publishing Cop Mafia

Vote Count 1 of Day 2

Not Voting (5) - Alex Steiner, Darth Skywalkerbacca, Reverse Simplicity, Sid_The_Kid, The King of Eggs

With 5 alive it's 3 to lynch.

Darth hasn't posted since Sunday ... I'll prod him.

I did tell you Alex was town he was righ when he said the N1 kill issue was to dumb to mistake so why on earth would you confirm Alex?

Let us not forget though that Alex is the only 100% confirmed townie and though I have no reason as of yet to doubt that you are the cop Eggs that doesn't mean you are it could have just been a really dumb cop mistake confirming the same person you cliamed you were going to confirm.

Darth Skywalkerbacca wrote:Let us not forget though that Alex is the only 100% confirmed townie and though I have no reason as of yet to doubt that you are the cop Eggs that doesn't mean you are it could have just been a really dumb cop mistake confirming the same person you cliamed you were going to confirm.

Doubting Eggs is silly. Everyone has posted? Real cop would have counterclaimed.

Vote Count 2 of Day 2

Not Voting (5) - Alex Steiner, Darth Skywalkerbacca, Reverse Simplicity, Sid_The_Kid, The King of Eggs

With 5 alive it's 3 to lynch.

I would like a bit more activity. If you guys don't start talking (voting optional), I'll impose a deadline for next week sometime.

That's why I said it could have been a really stupid cop mistake but again I think it unlikely. I'm not doubting as much as open to possibilities.

Darth Skywalkerbacca wrote:That's why I said it could have been a really stupid cop mistake but again I think it unlikely. I'm not doubting as much as open to possibilities.

Moving on.

To you 3:
Why are you not scum?

Why did you vote or not vote at critical times? (Answer as appropriate).

What other questions do you think would be good to ask?

Alex Steiner wrote:Why are you not scum?

*Giggles*

Alex Steiner wrote:Why did you vote or not vote at critical times? (Answer as appropriate).

I voted No Lynch, there was a plan, I agreed with said plan, so thats how I voted.

Alex Steiner wrote:What other questions do you think would be good to ask?

You are just being lazy... Direct questions specific to a person would be better, however you can ask a similar question to everyone to avoid scum realizing you suspect them.

Reverse Simplicity wrote:You are just being lazy...

Indeed I was. I am rereading now.

Sid_The_Kid wrote:ok with two omgus votes and with scum not jumping on the wagon i assume that both scum have voted ... either against each other ( mislead the town) or against one townie each ... and with a mislynch = town loss ... i assume that darth is not scum...unvote ...

Can you explain your reasoning behind this post? All the assumptions you made and deductions it took to come to the two main conclusions there.

Darth Skywalkerbacca wrote:lynch one scum today and confirm scum or town you will win anyway
confirm a townie that townie is safe from the next days lynch
the cop should try for the townie he most doubts or scum
the cop knows he's town we will know if what role who ever is confirmed is and then we can take our best bets that would be the esay way
just have to be sure we don't lynch the cop day one
but if we don't lynch scum day one there will be a definite night action

Can you do the same please?

Nothing specific for Reverse right now.

Can the three of you all state who you want to lynch first, and why.

Alex Steiner wrote:

Alex wrote:
I'm undecided on whether the cop should claim their investigation. Gives the scum the power to decide who to kill, whereas if the cop doesn't name their target, the scum is left guessing.

HOLY CRAP SORRY I EDITED INSTEAD OF QUOTING! FUCK i'M SORRY ~ THE KING OF EGGS

WTFRandom. I would have just put everything back where you found it and maybe mentioned it in your next post (depending on how long it took for you to realise). Still. Be careful.

For future reference, why did you investigate me?

Eggs, am I right in saying that those three are free to vote? As long as the townie doesn't vote for either of us, there's no way for scum to force a lynch?

Alex Steiner wrote:Eggs, am I right in saying that those three are free to vote? As long as the townie doesn't vote for either of us, there's no way for scum to force a lynch?

Yes of course. Since either you or I are required to vote to lynch (unless one of us is the target for some reason 0.o) the other three may vote as they please. In fact I encourage them.

However I must wonder why you asked me that 0.o... and as to your previous question. I investigated you, because you were not playing the same as usual (to my eyes) its was confusing. I was still fairly sure you were town though... However with no one else giving me anything to go on I picked you.

Darth: you rarely vote, however if you are town then in order for us to win we would require you to vote (unless the mafia run a bus). My question is this. Will you vote if required? And if so, what is your definition of 'required'

Reverse: If you were Scum (not saying your not of course ) what would your strategy be at this juncture.

Sid: Who do you believe tonight's kill will be and why? Or perhaps do you believe there will be no Nightkill? post reasons either way.

And finally:

SO: -.-

The King of Eggs wrote:Reverse: If you were Scum (not saying your not of course ) what would your strategy be at this juncture.

Since its 3 votes to lynch, all that is required for a scum win is for either Alex or yourself to vote the remaining townie. Mafia would double wagon victim. A bus may work in this situation, but that would require a specific, and unlikely, situation, This would also be quite a dangerous move, compared to laying low until the townie is accused.

And my question? Who do we lynch first, and why?

Alex Steiner wrote:Can the three of you all state who you want to lynch first, and why.

Not at this point no. Thats why I am enjoying the fact that Eggs put you in that position instead of me

I would have investigated Sid if I was cop, gut feeling more than anything. If I had to vote this very second or I would auto loss, it would be for him.

Vote Count 3 of Day 2

Not Voting (5) - Alex Steiner, Darth Skywalkerbacca, Reverse Simplicity, Sid_The_Kid, The King of Eggs

With 5 alive it's 3 to lynch.

Acticity's alright at the moment.
Prodding Sid, who hasn't posted since Monday

The King of Eggs wrote:SO: -.-

I've modkilled for less.

Supreme Overlord wrote:

The King of Eggs wrote:SO: -.-

I've modkilled for less.

No you haven't -.-

I'VE GOT IT


VOTE: SO

It makes perfect sense!

The King of Eggs wrote:

Supreme Overlord wrote:

The King of Eggs wrote:SO: -.-

I've modkilled for less.

No you haven't -.-

SO plays on Mafiascum and probably other places, noob.

Reverse Simplicity wrote:

The King of Eggs wrote:

Supreme Overlord wrote:

The King of Eggs wrote:SO: -.-

I've modkilled for less.

No you haven't -.-

SO plays on Mafiascum and probably other places, noob.

I doubt he mods though.

He's all talk.

Back to the game though please.

Alex Steiner wrote:

Reverse Simplicity wrote:

The King of Eggs wrote:

Supreme Overlord wrote:

The King of Eggs wrote:SO: -.-

I've modkilled for less.

No you haven't -.-

SO plays on Mafiascum and probably other places, noob.

I doubt he mods though.

He's all talk.

Back to the game though please.

What game?

Reverse Simplicity wrote:

Alex Steiner wrote:Back to the game though please.

What game?

The Game.

Alex Steiner wrote:

Reverse Simplicity wrote:

Alex Steiner wrote:Back to the game though please.

What game?

The Game.

YOU MONSTER!

FoS: Alex Steiner

You deserved it RS

PS: Alex... Screw you :/, RS deserved it but I didn't :'(

As for Alex's question about my post I was right wasn't I?
My point was if two scum go into day 2 there will be at least one night kill as you can only lynch one person per day.

As for Eggs question no I do not vote at least I haven't voted since our first game back on Quick Topic (ahh good times) why because Overlord and his awesome debating skills convinced me that I shouldn't need to if the town are at all competent they will identify the scum before they to employ every town vote to win.
As for voting if requiered no I won't if town lynch scum today there will be at least 2 town left to lynch scum tomorrow 3 if the scum are especially stupid or lazy.

DARTH: ARE YOU FORGETTING THAT WE LITERALLY REQUIRE YOU TO VOTE TO LYNCH :/

AS: the statement was what i saw as quick mafia win from that piont ... and since you hadn't done anything that seemed scummy i didn't wanna give the scum a free shot ... of course in hindsight i see that my lack of research on players left me with an inaccurate conclusion ...
Eggs: well it would be very stupid for the scum to lynch the unknown townie as this would make it easy for you and AS to know who the scum are ... as for the possibility of a no night kill i can't see a logical reason why the scum would not utilise thier weaponry ...