Reverse Simplicity Mafia Scum (V1)

I was roleblocked after attempting to kill Mikey. Rewind; your kill claim and Eggs, your RB or not claim please

Not Roleblocked

Just Rewind's kill claim to go. Isn't this fun.

I was going to try and kill Mikey but I got role blocked first

Where do we go from here? That is every claim, what are the errors?

Eggs has a point how are we gona tell scum from town if everyone is telling the truth.
Even if they are scum or not, they still hav killing and/or roleblocking abilities meaning that what they are claiming may be the truth

Mikey the idea is that we know the numbers of town roles, so we can narrow down a little, but yes if everyone is truthfull then we haven't gained much, no death info kinda sucks

Vote: Mikey
Wanna know why? He roleblocked a claimed, proven town vigilante in Rewind. Unless you can think of an extremely good excuse, I think we've found another scum.

At this point in time im not sure if anyone is telling the truth on who they are, how do you know that rewind is a vig and not a scum or SK. All of them can kill.

I just roleblocked him because even if he was a vig, he can still kill. And i do not think we need a kill right now,(except for lynch) beacause it is all undecided and there is a higher chance of killing a town, than it is to kill mafia or SK.

We know that Rewind is a town vigilante because there are only 2 vigilantes in the game, and only 2 people have claimed vigilante. Since townies should not lie, Rewind and I are the vigilantes, and therefore confirmed town.

This was said before night, so, even as a townie, you should have let Rewind exercise his own judgement on whether or not to kill, rather than imposing your own roleblock on him. In fact, you should have roleblocked either Eggs or Alex, because since at least one of them was lying, they had access to a kill, and you could have blocked an anti-town kill rather than a town-motivated one (side note: it is statistically good for the town to introduce a ‘random’ kill that cannot hit the vigilante themselves).

The previous paragraph is the scenarios assuming Mikey is town, which I doubt. Vote stays.

feel free to RoleBLock me in future. RoleBlockers don't effect each other last time I checked.

Roleblock priority: Kill>Roleblock Although when informed of the roleblock you are not told what abilities didnt work.

The roleblockers should only be roleblocking each other at this point; they're the only ones who can possibly have kills that they're hiding. Hence I'm voting Mikey for blocking a vig.

Very true. I agree Vote: Mikey Boy

Still if i didnt block Rewind i would have died. A vig against a roleblocking mafia, or a roleblocking SK is worthless.

They just block the vig and then kill him. Makig me (town roleblocker) a very important part i the town's survival

Mikey wrote:Still if i didnt block Rewind i would have died.

And we would have killed a scum with 50% to 100% certainty.

Mikey wrote:A vig against a roleblocking mafia, or a roleblocking SK is worthless.

And a town RB is worse than useless; that's why this game has to be won on lynches. That's also why we're lynching you.

Rewind, an opinion here would be nice.

I'm not too sure because I know how Mike thinks and it sounds like something he would do especially after getting vig killed in mk. 2 but on the other hand what you say makes sense. I'm not going to vote yet but I am kind of suspicious.

Does it seem more likely he would do this as town or scum? He seems extremely interested in self-preservation at the moment.

Also, remember, if you think Mikey is town, that means Eggs has to be scum. That much is guarenteed.

Then Obviously MB is scum.

Have I voted yet?

Unvote [IINT?]: Vote Mikey Boy

BUMP
Rewind, an opinion here. At least one of Mikey and Eggs has to be scum. Which one?
Mod: A votecount? Hoe's deadline going?

hmmm I don't think anything eggs has done is wrong so I suppose Mike sounds like scum. but I'm not too sure about however I won't vote until nearer the deadline so I can be sure (sorry if this is kinda Darthy but I want to be sure).

Rewind we don't know the deadline?

Vote count...
Mikey (L-2) (SO)

What a waste....

Deadline will be 12:30 Wednesday 10/11/2010

http://www.timeanddate.com/counters/customcounter.html?day=10&month=11&year=2010&hour=12&min=30&sec=&p0=47

Rewind, what are you waiting for; what do you think might develop closer to deadline that will make you more (or less) sure of Mikey?

This may be a little late, but why did you attempt to kill Mikey last night?

I attempted to kill him because I thought he was the most likley to be scum however I'm starting to have doubts because eggs jumped straight on the lynch idea and is pushing hard for it. still I will probalby vote him I just don't want to yet just incase somthing else develops closer to the deadline.

PS: also note he hasn't voted back at either of you even though your voting for him.

IF i vote back, they will take it as a scummy action. Which is another reason they can use to target me.