Revolving Door Afterlife Mafia (Game Over)

Please enlighten me on how you came to that conclusion. ''He voted for both'' please expand.

Actually forget it. Don't explain or provide evidence. I'll go along with him being SK.

Doesn't mean he shouldn't be lynched.

People seem far too invested in this, getting mad at game. Have arguments, but try not to get mad at people while constructing or refuting them.

Reverse's recent play is weirding me out. Not sure what to make of it.

Who do we want Darth to strangle, assuming all he said is true?
Who do we want to lynch?

Do we want more kills or more info? I'm leaning towards more info, which implies a Darth lynch. killing off 2 people, not knowing who is what, seems like a bad idea.

Thats exactly what I have been trying to get accross. But yeah after reading my posts... It seems like I may have flipped out a bit.

I took on a lot of new commitments recently, which has me tired and easily irritable. I appologise, I will do my best to post with a level head from now.

Also now I understand what eggs was getting at. I should not have been posting after midnight.

ok this is good today seems to finally be getting on track

@Alex - How would lynching me provide more information? (Also really if you think about it with a lynch, my night kill and mafia night kill, there will be three deaths)
@Eggs - ok your points explanation sounds reasonable (have there actually been any points related roles other than Walt's so far? I will admit to not paying that much attention in the mid days, but it seems unlikely that Overlord would add the mechanic and not put it to good use which makes me think there will be more point related roles Today)

Anyway shall we take advantage of the cessation of my and Reverse's disagreement and concentrate on scum. I know me and Reverse/Walt have been the major posters of Day 5 so what does everybody else think, scum lists maybe? or at least preferred lynch list?

I would be happiest if Darth didn't strangle anyone.

Darth can we do a no kill vote?

Also I agree RS is acting a little bit weird compared to his normal play. Also eventually we will have to decide whether to lynch him or not and if we can't get two people who we think are mafia it seems like a hard decision. Also we have no proof he is neutral except for his claim.

Ill say [b]@Darthkill:no kill

*@darthkill: no kill

Vote Count 10 of Day 5

Walt the Alt (2; L-2): Jayden1222, Darth Skywalkerbacca
Darth Skywalkerbacca (2; L-2): Walt the Alt, Reverse Simplicity


Not Voting (3): Sid_The_Kid, The King of Eggs, Alex Steiner

With 7 votes in play, it’s 4 to lynch.
Deadline is 1pm, Tuesday 7th May.

if we want darth not to strangle anyone why not lynch him today rather than trusting him ?

pokemon strawberries.

I have nothing to add, does anyone have any important things to claim?

I find it odd that Alex, Eggs and Sid haven't really voted today (haven't been a big part of any of the to and fro, normally they're the largest posters) we really need more participation today especially now that we're nearing the end of Day 5.

Otherwise nothing has really happened to comment on (Sorry Overlord)

If I accept that darth is SK. My next pick for scum is still eggs. It is still just a vibe of his play.

Unvote
WaltUnvote
Vote: Eggs
WaltVote: Eggs
DarthNK: Alex

It was indeed alexs suggestion that we need more info. I believe alexs death could provide that.

I'm going to vote for darth because I don't think we will find two/three people we feel the need to lynch/kill. So one will be satisfactory. As well as for points and to get a new day rolling.
Vote:Darth

Vote Count 11 of Day 5

Walt the Alt (1; L-3): Darth Skywalkerbacca
The King of Eggs (2; L-2): Reverse Simplicity, Walt the Alt
Darth Skywalkerbacca (1; L-3): Jayden1222


Not Voting (3): Sid_The_Kid, The King of Eggs, Alex Steiner

With 7 votes in play, it’s 4 to lynch.
Deadline is 1pm, Tuesday 7th May.

Alex and Jayden were prodded; this was Alex's second, and Jayden's first prod for Day 5.

^ Vote count error. Walt and Darth should be (1; L-3)

Mod Note: Quite so. Fixed.

Vote: Darth

I didn't want him at L-1, but since Reverse has flipped (again), I guess it's safer to do so.

inb4 Reverse flips back

We need info from who lives more than who dies. Worst case we lose 3 townies at once. If we lynch Darth, worst case we lose 1.

Reverse Simplicity wrote:If I accept that darth is SK. My next pick for scum is still eggs. It is still just a vibe of his play.

Unvote
WaltUnvote
Vote: Eggs
WaltVote: Eggs
DarthNK: Alex

It was indeed alexs suggestion that we need more info. I believe alexs death could provide that.

That's a lot of voting.

So, one minute, I'm scum because I'm not acting like scum, nek minnit, you have a "vibe"?

silly RS, Vibe had a 10% margin of error

Silly Eggs. What I decide to call why I think you are scum is irrelevant.

Who do you think the scum team is most likely to be?

Vote:Darth
I see very little reason for you to remain
> We have to kill you at some point
> Tonight we loose a townie ( you're only a threat to scum if your target is scum (unless there is only one) )
> if it gets down to 4 players ( you, scum and 2xtown) town looses
> We have no major scum suspects
> Your death removes any possibility of betrayal or town misaiming your kill

Although a Darth lynch doesn't give us any information ( assuming claim accuracy ) it removes risks and allows tomorrow to be focused completely on the information from today and tonight, whereas lynching a random suspect increases risk of loosing a towny whilst maintaining any risks Darth's death reduces
As for why i didn't vote earlier i need the points ( thus a higher wagon position), plus at the time i was unsure just how Darth's death/survival would play out for the game

Edit: town can win if Darth survives to the last 4 ( if scum kills Darth)

Vote Count 12 of Day 5

Walt the Alt (1; L-3): Darth Skywalkerbacca
The King of Eggs (2; L-2): Reverse Simplicity, Walt the Alt
Darth Skywalkerbacca (3; L-1): Jayden1222, Alex Steiner, Sid_The_Kid


Not Voting (1): The King of Eggs

With 7 votes in play, it’s 4 to lynch.
Deadline is 1pm, Tuesday 7th May.

Since we already 'know' (Ha see, I can comprehend) that darth is SK, we will be gaining no info by his lynch. Unless you think that darth is lying and is actually scum.

The people voting darth I ask you to please re evaluate your position, we are more likely to get helpful information if someone who spawned today is lynched. I suspect that if Darth and Sid are not scum buddies, then Darth would have probably killed Sid to gain advantage today.

I know, I know, this is a complete flip from my behaviour today, but I did say that I was going to do my best to post with a clear head. This is my opinion after my own reevaluation.

@RS i'm all for information , i just think that removing darth will give us clearer information in the future whilst not risking a mislynch
@Alex and Jayden The more points i get the more detailed investigation i can do , thus more information i can recieve , thus would you mind unvoting and revoting to reposition me towards the front of the wagon?